Response to ASX Query Letter
Released
Released
Announcement PDF
18 March 2025
Caitlyn Cooke
ASX Compliance Pty Ltd
Level 40, Central Park
152-158 St Georges Tce
Perth WA 6000
By Email: ListingsCompliancePerth@asx.com.au (cc: Caitlyn.Cooke@asx.com.au)
Dear Caitlyn
Victory Metals Limited: Query
Victory Metals Limited (ASX:VTM) (“Company” or “VTM”) refers to the ASX query letter dated
12 March 2025 (“Query Letter”). The Company’s responses to the questions set out in the
Query Letter are set out below.
Unless otherwise defined, capitalised terms used in this letter have the meaning given in the
Query Letter.
1.
Did VTM, or anyone representing VTM, provide a statement to the media concerning the
information in the Article?
Yes.
2.
If the answer to question 1 is ‘yes’:
2.1 Please provide a copy of that correspondence (not for release to the market);
Refer to the attached documentation.
2.2 Explain when (time and date), and by whom, the information was first provided to the
media; and
The information was provided in the form of a media release marked 'Embargoed Until:
Released on ASX' ("Media Release") by Company CEO and Executive Director, Mr Brendan
Clark; Company Strategic Advisor, Ms Alannah MacTiernan; and Investor Relations advisor,
Mr Ben Creagh via email and text message at various times on Friday, 7 March 2025 and
Monday, 10 March 2025, as outlined below.
1. On Friday, 7 March 2025, Ms MacTiernan sent text messages attaching the Media
Release to Isabel Vieira of WA Business News at 10:11am and Brad Thompson of The
Australian at 12:13pm.
2. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 12:45pm AWST, Mr Clark sent an email attaching the
Media Release to T Zaunmayr of WA Business News.
ACN: 124 279 750
E: info@victorymetalsaustralia.com D: +61 (08) 6555 2950 A: Suite 1, 295 Rokeby Road, Subiaco, WA, 6008
3. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 3:29pm AWST, Mr Clark sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Adrian Rauso of The West Australian.
4. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 5:40pm AWST, Mr Creagh sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Brad Thompson of The Australian.
5. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 5:43pm AWST, Mr Creagh sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Adrian Rauso of The West Australian.
6. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 5:47pm AWST, Mr Creagh sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Elouise Fowler of The Australian Financial Review.
7. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 6:14pm AWST, Mr Clark sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Rebecca Page of Mining.com.
8. On Monday, 10 March 2025 at 7:14pm AWST, Mr Clark sent an email attaching the
Media Release to Louis Allen at Stockhead.
The Media Release and the above correspondence is attached to this Letter.
2.3 Does VTM consider this compliant with Listing Rule 15.7? If so, please explain the basis
for that view.
No. Notwithstanding that the Media Release was clearly labelled as 'Embargoed Until:
Released on ASX', the Company acknowledges that the communications outlined in the answer
to question 2.2 are not in compliance with Listing Rule 15.7.
If the answer to question 1 is ‘no’, is there any other explanation as to how the
information appeared in the Article?
N/A.
3.
What arrangements does VTM have in place to ensure compliance with Listing Rule
15.7?
The Company has in place a Continuous Disclosure Policy, available on its website at
https://www.victorymetalsaustralia.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/1VG-CorporateGovernance-Policies.pdf. The Continuous Disclosure Policy is available to all directors and
executives of the Company and each Board member, Executive and Senior Employee is aware
of its existence and contents.
Relevantly, the Company's Continuous Disclosure Policy includes, as a guiding principle:
The Company will ensure that it does not communicate material price sensitive
information to an external party except where that information has previously been
disclosed to the ASX.
Under the Company's Continuous Disclosure Policy, only the Chairman, Executive Director, or
their nominated delegates are authorised to make public statements to the media, however,
this authority does not extend to releasing publicly any information required to be disclosed
through the ASX until released by the ASX.
ACN: 124 279 750
E: info@victorymetalsaustralia.com D: +61 (08) 6555 2950 A: Suite 1, 295 Rokeby Road, Subiaco, WA, 6008
The Company takes its disclosure obligations and compliance with the Listing Rules seriously,
and regrets the non-compliance set out in the answer to question 2.3 above.
In relation to this non-compliance, the Company notes the following:
4.
•
Prior to providing the Media Release to any third parties, the Company requested a
trading halt, and at no point following the confidential distribution of the Media Release
and prior to release of the Announcement were the Company's securities trading.
•
Upon becoming aware of the delay in the release of the Announcement, the Company
took steps to prevent the publication of any media articles concerning the Media
Release. Other than the Article, no other media reports were published in relation to
the results of the Company's Scoping Study prior to the release of the Announcement.
•
Following due enquiries, the Company became aware that the Article was to be
published in print prior to the approval and release of the Announcement on the MAP.
The Company immediately requested that the Article not be printed or further
distributed (see attached correspondence between Mr Clark and Adrian Rauso).
•
Once the Company became aware that the Article was going to be published prior to
the release of the Announcement, and prior to the commencement of trading on
Tuesday, 11 March 2025,the Company notified ASX that was aware of the Article and
potential further media report in relation to the Company's scoping study. The Company
also sought to provide an update through the MAP, cautioning investors not to rely on
the information in the Article or any other media reports in relation to the results of the
Company's scoping study. This announcement was not released on the MAP by ASX.
In light of the Article, what additional steps will VTM take to ensure compliance with
Listing Rule 15.7?
The Company has discussed the beach of Listing Rule 15.7 with its CEO and Executive
Director, Company Strategic Advisor and Investor Relations Adviser.
The Company intends to conduct an internal review of the circumstance under which the Media
Release was disseminated to various media outlets. Following that review, the Company will,
at a minimum, provide training to all Board members, Executive and Senior Employees in
relation to its continuous disclosure policy and compliance with the Listing Rules, including
Listing Rule 15.7.
In relation to future price sensitive announcements, the Company intends to establish additional
procedures to ensure the Company's compliance with the Listing Rules, including Listing Rule
15.7.
The Company is confident that. irrespective of the non-compliance, which is considered to be
isolated, the necessary steps and internal governance measures will be undertaken, to ensure
that such non-compliance will not be repeated.
5.
Please confirm that VTM’s responses to the above have been authorised and approved
under its published continuous disclosure policy or otherwise by its board or an officer
of VTM with delegated authority from the board to respond to ASX on disclosure matters.
The Company confirms that its response has been authorised and approved by officers of the
Company that have delegated authority from the Board to respond to ASX disclosure matters.
ACN: 124 279 750
E: info@victorymetalsaustralia.com D: +61 (08) 6555 2950 A: Suite 1, 295 Rokeby Road, Subiaco, WA, 6008
Yours faithfully,
Robbie Featherby
Company Secretary
Victory Metals Limited
ACN: 124 279 750
E: info@victorymetalsaustralia.com D: +61 (08) 6555 2950 A: Suite 1, 295 Rokeby Road, Subiaco, WA, 6008
12 March 2025
Mr Robbie Featherby
Company Secretary
Victory Metals Limited
By email: robbie@sccperth.com.au
Dear Mr Featherby
Victory Metals Limited (‘VTM’): Early release of information - Query
ASX refers to the following:
A. The article appearing in the West Australian under the headline “Declaring Victory on $340M Rare Earths
Plan” (the ‘Article’) on 11 March 2025, which included the following information in relation to a scoping
study contemplated by VTM for its North Stanmore project:
(i) The CAPEX will be $337,000,000;
(ii) The NPV will be $1,200,000,000;
(iii) The IRR will be 52%; and
(iv) The life of mine will be 31 years.
B. VTM’s announcement entitled “OUTSTANDING NORTH STANMORE SCOPING STUDY DELIVERED IN TIER 1
MINING JURISDICTION” released on the ASX Market Announcements Platform (‘MAP’) at 6:37am AWST on
12 March 2025 in which VTM disclosed an estimated:
(i) CAPEX of $337,000,000;
(ii) NPV of $1,212,000,000;
(iii) Post Tax IRR of 52%; and
(iv) 31 year life of mine.
(the ‘Announcement’).
C. Listing Rule 3.1 which states:
“Once an entity is or becomes aware of any information concerning it that a reasonable person would
expect to have a material effect on the price or value of the entity’s securities, the entity must
immediately tell ASX that information”
D. Listing Rule 15.7 which states:
“An entity must not release information that is for release to the market to any person until it has
given the information to ASX and has received an acknowledgment that ASX has released information
to the market.”
E. The note to Listing Rule 15.7 which states:
“Note: This rule prohibits an entity giving information to the media even on an embargoed basis.”
As the Article was published prior to the Announcement being released on MAP, it appears that VTM may have
breached Listing Rules 3.1 and/or 15.7.
ASX Limited [[Listings]]
#10876741v1
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
Request for information
Having regard to the above, ASX asks VTM to respond separately to each of the following questions and
requests for information:
1. Did VTM, or anyone representing VTM, provide a statement to the media concerning the information in the
Article?
2. If the answer to question 1 is ‘yes’:
2.1
Please provide a copy of that correspondence (not for release to the market);
2.2
Explain when (time and date), and by whom, the information was first provided to the media; and
2.3
Does VTM consider this compliant with Listing Rule 15.7? If so, please explain the basis for that view.
3. If the answer to question 1 is ‘no’, is there any other explanation as to how the information appeared in the
Article?
4. What arrangements does VTM have in place to ensure compliance with Listing Rule 15.7?
5. In light of the Article, what additional steps will VTM take to ensure compliance with Listing Rule 15.7?
6. Please confirm that VTM’s responses to the above have been authorised and approved under its published
continuous disclosure policy or otherwise by its board or an officer of VTM with delegated authority from
the board to respond to ASX on disclosure matters.
ASX expects VTM to make reasonable enquiries to put itself in a position to answer the questions above.
When and where to send your response
This request is made under Listing Rule 18.7. Your response is required as soon as reasonably possible and, in
any event, by no later than 12 PM AWST Friday, 14 March 2025. Your response should be sent by e-mail to
ListingsCompliancePerth@asx.com.au. It should not be sent directly to the ASX Market Announcements Office.
Release of correspondence between ASX and entity
We reserve the right to release all or any part of this letter, your reply and any other related correspondence
between us to the market under listing rule 18.7A.
Yours sincerely
ASX Compliance
2/2
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
#10876741v1
Share your feedback
Discover